I got a pair of seconds from Kevin and honestly, i wouldn't have thought these were anything but firsts. A little wrinkling of the bison on the quarters, but it was going to do that after 1 wear anyway.
The fit is great at true to size. Feels very solid on foot and almost disappears, in a good way. No hot spots, pinching etc.
I will say that the toe is longer\pointier than i thought it would be from the product and review photos. More dressy than i imagined.
The bison is awesome. i have a pair of Grant Stone field boot moc toes made with Seidel's bison. This is similar visually, but the "glaze" elevates it from a workbook type leather, to a more sophisticated feel while still capturing the neat variation of bison. Sunlight really brings out the reds.